Most boards complete an annual evaluation. Far fewer act on it. This guide shows how to design an evaluation that meets the legal requirements and actually improves how the board works.
In India, board evaluation is a legal requirement for listed and certain other companies. Section 134(3)(p) of the Companies Act 2013 requires the board's report to state how the formal annual evaluation of the board, its committees and individual directors was carried out. Section 178 gives the Nomination and Remuneration Committee a role in specifying the manner of evaluation. Schedule IV and SEBI LODR Regulations 17(10) and 25(4) set out the evaluation of independent directors by the board and the review undertaken by independent directors at their separate meeting.
The result, too often, is a questionnaire filled in once a year, averaged into a score and summarised in a sentence in the annual report. Compliance is achieved. Nothing changes. Here is how to do better.
Start with the purpose, not the questionnaire
Before choosing a method, the chairperson and NRC should agree what the evaluation is for this year. Examples:
- Is the board spending enough time on strategy compared with compliance?
- Is the information flow from management timely and useful?
- Does the board have the skills it needs for the next three years?
- Are committees working well together, or duplicating effort?
- Is the relationship between the board and the promoter group healthy?
A focused evaluation on two or three themes will yield more than a generic survey of forty questions.
Choose the right method
Questionnaire
Efficient and comparable year on year, but it rarely surfaces sensitive issues. Use rating scales sparingly and always include open questions such as "What one change would most improve this board?"
One-to-one interviews
Conducted by the chairperson, the senior independent director or the NRC chair, interviews draw out issues people will not write down. They take more time and depend on the interviewer's skill and neutrality.
Externally facilitated review
An independent facilitator, perhaps every two or three years, brings objectivity and benchmarking, and can observe a board meeting. Ensure the facilitator has no other relationship with the company that could compromise their independence.
Cover all four levels
- The board as a whole: composition, strategy, risk oversight, culture, meeting effectiveness.
- Committees: clarity of terms of reference, quality of reporting to the board, workload.
- The chairperson: reviewed at the separate meeting of independent directors, taking into account the views of executive and non-executive directors.
- Individual directors: preparation, contribution, independence of judgement, and, for independent directors, fulfilment of the independence criteria. The director being evaluated does not take part in their own evaluation.
Ask better questions
Replace vague items such as "The board functions effectively" with specific, observable ones:
- "Board papers arrive early enough for me to prepare properly."
- "In the past year, the board changed or stopped a management proposal after discussion."
- "Dissenting views are recorded accurately in the minutes."
- "I understand the company's three most significant risks and how they are being managed."
- "The board has discussed CEO and senior management succession in the past twelve months."
Turn findings into actions
This is where most evaluations fail. A simple discipline helps:
- The chairperson presents a short summary of themes, not raw scores, to the full board.
- The board agrees no more than five actions, each with an owner and a deadline.
- Actions are tracked on the board's agenda, at least quarterly.
- The next year's evaluation begins by asking whether last year's actions worked.
An evaluation that produces no change is not a neutral result. It tells directors the exercise does not matter, and next year's answers will be less candid.
Handle individual feedback with care
Individual feedback is the most valuable and most sensitive output. Good practice:
- Deliver it privately, through the chairperson or NRC chair.
- Focus on behaviour and contribution, not personality.
- Link it to development: training, committee rotation or mentoring.
- Use it to inform reappointment decisions. For an independent director, the extension or continuation of a term should be based on the performance evaluation report.
Disclose meaningfully
Disclosure in the board's report and corporate governance report should explain the process, the criteria and, where possible, the broad outcomes and actions. Readers learn more from "the board agreed to increase time on technology risk and to refresh the skills matrix" than from a statement that the evaluation was "carried out satisfactorily".
Quick checklist for company secretaries
- Evaluation criteria approved by the NRC and documented.
- Separate meeting of independent directors scheduled and minuted.
- Confidentiality of responses protected.
- Action plan circulated and tracked.
- Board report disclosure drafted from the actual process followed.
VOLO works with boards to design evaluations that focus on change, and VOLO's Director Readiness programme (IDRP™) prepares directors to give and receive candid peer feedback.
